It seems more likely that this bias is akin to misclassification in epidemiological studies, and hence would lead to underestimates of associations. Furthermore, a sensitivity analysis excluding patient follow-up where smoking data were missing gave similar results. We therefore believe that the decreases in risk of CVD following smoking cessation that we have seen can be interpreted robustly. Secondly, in our analyses we adjusted for time-updated lipid and blood

pressure measurements. These are variables that might be expected to improve on stopping smoking, leading to issues around time-varying confounding. We did not use more complex statistical models that attempt to this website account for such confounding, such as marginal structural models, given the very small mean changes in such variables that we observed. By including changes in lipids and blood pressure post stopping smoking, if these variables improved as a result of stopping smoking, then the risk predicted by the model would be reduced, and yet we still observed a decrease in the adjusted risk of CVD after stopping. Hence, the analyses we performed that did adjust for time-updated changes in these variables would be expected to lead to underestimates of the reduction in CVD risk, again suggesting that our observed decrease

in CVD risk can be interpreted check details robustly. Thirdly, we do not collect reasons for stopping smoking or any other health behaviour data, and it is possible that stopping smoking may have been accompanied by other beneficial lifestyle changes such as improved diet, increased exercise and reduced recreational drug use, which may also explain the observed lower rates among patients who stopped smoking. Hence we cannot exclude the possibility that some of the observed decrease in CVD risk may be attributable to other improved lifestyle behaviours and not entirely to stopping smoking. Finally, we did not have any historical smoking data (prior to entry into D:A:D), and therefore we were unable to accurately determine the number of attempts Phospholipase D1 at stopping smoking in this

population. However, other studies have reported that at least 70% of HIV-positive patients who were regular smokers had tried stopping at least once before [2,5], 42% after their HIV diagnosis [2], which is consistent with what we observed during D:A:D follow-up. In conclusion, we found that rates of CVD decreased in HIV-positive patients who stopped smoking. Successfully stopping smoking can reduce the overall disease burden of HIV-positive patients and improve their quality of life, and smoking cessation efforts should be made a priority in the clinical management of HIV-positive patients. This will require research into identifying the most effective smoking cessation approaches in HIV-positive patients.